causal

Step-Wise Argument to Repugnant Conclusion

The repugnant conclusion follows from a chain where each step seems an improvement: adding lower-but-positive lives harms no one, then leveling everyone toward equality at a slightly lower top raises total well-being and equality, and repeating this process drives the population toward enormous numbers of barely-worth-living lives, with no obvious point at which the chain can be stopped.

causalpending

Speaker

David Edmonds

Evidence Quote

that's how you end up with the repugnant conclusion so it is quite complicated but the logic of it seems completely robust and he couldn't find a way of of stopping that chain

Source

321 - Reckoning With ParfitMaking Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:18:06 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...