Bueno de Mesquita's 'selectorate' theory fits the limited/open access distinction: small selectorates (e.g., a Politburo) lead states to distribute private goods, while large selectorates (all adult citizens) lead to public goods; but his theory takes the state's monopoly on violence and the selectorate size as given, whereas Weingast argues you must explain how states form by how they solve the problem of violence.

causalpending

Speaker

Barry Weingast

Evidence Quote

most models of the state bueno de Mesquita at all in particular think about begin with the state as taking it as given that you have a state it has a monopoly on violence... we argue that you can't start there

Source

Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:04:08 PM

My Notes

Loading notes...