factual

Coin flips give legitimate 'could have done otherwise'

A fair coin flip is not random but determined by the position of every particle in the visible universe, yet it could have been otherwise in an important sense — its outcome is uncaused in that it has no salient cause — so we use coin flips to implement 'could have done otherwise' when needed; in a deterministic world some coin tosses are random (uncalibrated) and some aren't (a calibrated mercury-bath flipper always comes up heads), all without touching determinism.

factualpending

Speaker

Dan Dennett

Evidence Quote

that's a perfectly legitimate sense of could have done otherwise even though determinism reigns

Source

39 - Free Will RevisitedMaking Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:25:04 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...