causal

US Presidentialism Only Works in the US

Per Adam Przeworski's comparative research, the American-style system of presidentialism and separation of powers has only really worked in the United States; the many countries that copied it (all of Latin America) failed, because parliamentary systems have an escape valve—a vote of no confidence triggering an election—that presidential systems lack, allowing a hobbled party to stagger on while resentment builds, and the historic ideological overlap between US parties was part of what made the exceptional American system work.

causalpending

Speaker

Jean-Paul Faguet

Evidence Quote

Westminster style parliamentary democracy, where you have a really effective steam valve... when conflict gets very high, you just have a vote of no confidence, you bring down the government, it triggers an election

Source

287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of HistorySean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:04 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...