Geshe Lhakdor
About
Buddhist scholar; expert on Nagarjuna and Tibetan Buddhist philosophy
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Geshe Lhakdor's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Geshe Lhakdor (11)
There are three nested levels of dependent origination: (1) causal dependence—objects depend on causes and conditions for production and dissolution; (2) parthood dependence—objects depend on their constituent parts and the collection of those parts; (3) conceptual dependence—objects depend on mental imputation and labeling based on suitable bases.
A pen exists conventionally with properties like shape and color, but ultimately it depends on causes (material conditions, artisan action) for production and disintegration, and on parts (cap, body, ink) for its constitution—therefore it lacks independent existence from its own side.
Just as Rovelli found that the properties of particles emerge from interactions between them rather than inhering in individual particles, Nagarjuna teaches that objects (like a pen) emerge from the interplay of their constituent parts—neither the parts alone nor the collection exists from its own side.
A chair (or pen) cannot be located in any of its parts (armrests, legs, etc.), nor in their collection, nor in any spatiotemporal region; yet conventionally the chair exists; this illustrates that the chair exists only through conceptual imputation on a suitable material basis, not as an independently locatable entity.
My Notes
Loading notes...