Gillian Tett
About
Journalist; author of 'Fool's Gold'
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Gillian Tett's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Gillian Tett (20 of 21)
It is possible to reimagine and fix capitalism's flaws through combination of digital technology enabling more people to be empowered, being forced to widen lens beyond balance sheets to environmental factors, and through actual debate like this where previously opposed parties find more agreement than disagreement
Many companies are doing better environmentally today than they were two or three decades ago, suggesting that radical transparency and multiple stakeholders (government, companies, NGOs, citizens) working simultaneously produces environmental improvements even if motivated by diverse interests.
Adam Smith's theory of capitalism has two essential books: The Wealth of Nations (about competition and trade) and The Theory of Moral Sentiments (about shared moral ethical and legal foundations), and successful markets require four components: free access to markets, free access to transparent prices, alignment of ownership and management, and shared moral ethical and legal foundations
Wall Street in the early 2000s was missing all four of Adam Smith's components: people did not have equal access to markets due to powerful cartels controlling the show; prices were not transparently accessible; ownership and management were not aligned because pension funds outsourced decisions to asset managers; and there was no shared moral ethical framework
Barter—the exchange of data for services—is alive and thriving in silicon valley today; tech companies are running on wholesale swaps of data for services that do not involve money, and this is invisible in economic models and corporate valuations because economists treat it as free services
To reform tech today and create a more ethical tech system, you don't need to abolish barter but rather change the terms of trade by (1) increasing transparency about how data is used, (2) increasing transparency about what companies do with data inside the company, and most crucially (3) enabling data portability so consumers can pull their data out and switch to competitors
Green growth and environmental solutions require moving beyond tunnel vision economic models and balance sheets that treat the environment as an externality or footprint; companies should measure and include environmental costs in valuations using impact-weighted accounting and environmental social governance accounting
Transparency and information access have radically increased today compared to past decades—whether through leaked papers like the Pandora Papers or social movements like #MeToo that use information-sharing platforms to coalesce fragmented and powerless women—demonstrating that information distribution has shifted from tightly held vertical hierarchies to more democratic access
Not everyone gets their news from newspapers anymore—people get news from internet sites that have the capacity to dominate the internet, which are the same corporate interests, so claims about radical transparency and information democratization underestimate continued concentration of media power
Anthropology teaches that immersing yourself in the lives of others who seem strange allows you to get empathy and understanding of different ways of doing things, and also allows you to see yourself and your own assumptions more clearly—like how fish can't see water unless they jump out of their fishbowl
Milton Friedman's shareholder capitalism model from the 1970s operated under assumptions that are no longer valid: that people could outsource social and ethical decisions to governments while companies focused on balance sheets, and that people did not have information access; today people distrust government and have radical information access
Anthropological perspective on capitalism reveals that many aspects of capitalism's supposed failures (barter, non-market exchange, different ownership models) have existed successfully in human societies for millennia, suggesting that today's capitalism is culturally specific rather than natural or inevitable.
The word 'finance' comes from Old French 'veneer' meaning 'to finish', suggesting that finance was originally about paying off debts and finishing actual tangible commercial transactions—a means to an end—rather than endless loops of money creating speculation that is an end in itself
My Notes
Loading notes...