Peter Singer
About
Moral philosopher at Princeton University, utilitarian, author of Animal Liberation
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Peter Singer's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Peter Singer (20 of 243)
Steven Pinker wrote in Better Angels of Nature that when he was a graduate student in psychology, he conducted what he describes as one of the worst things he's ever done—torturing a rat to death—but claimed that the difference between the 1960s and present time is 'like the difference between night and day,' though this claim appears to be false based on current animal research practices.
Singer's Animal Liberation was well-received by philosophers in the 1970s, with most who engaged with it saying that philosophy should return to addressing important ethical questions, partly because other philosophers were already discussing Vietnam, civil disobedience, and civil rights.
The term 'speciesism' was not invented by Singer but was found in a leaflet published in the early 1970s by Richard Ryder, and when Singer encountered it, it provided a conceptual framework parallel to racism and sexism for understanding unjustified discrimination based on species membership.
The slippery slope argument against euthanasia was widely used in Netherlands debates in the 1980s when voluntary medical assistance in dying began, with opponents predicting it would lead to killing people regarded as useless, intellectually disabled, or politically undesirable, though this argument seemed to have weight because the practice was unfamiliar at the time.
The key difference between justified and unjustified discrimination is not the characteristics of the discriminated group but whether the discriminating group's interests actually override the other group's interests; being of one race, sex, or species does not provide such moral override, but capacity for suffering does.
There are small numbers of farms that do treat animals well, give them good lives, and kill them without suffering, and if an animal that has lived a net positive life is killed humanely, purchasing products from such farms may not be ethically harmful because the animal would not have existed at all if not for the market demand.
Speciesism operates through the same mechanism as racism and sexism: a dominant group uses technological or other advantages to subjugate another group, then develops an ideology to justify that subjugation, as when Europeans used technology to enslave Africans and developed ideologies of racial superiority, or when male-dominated societies denied women property rights and voting rights.
An anencephalic infant (born with only a brain stem, no cerebrum, destined never to be conscious) has less moral significance than a dog, cow, or pig because those animals can experience things and have good or bad lives from their perspective, whereas the anencephalic infant will never have conscious experiences.
Learned helplessness experiments in dogs involved training dogs to escape electric shock, then placing barriers to prevent escape, causing dogs to stop attempting escape after repeated shocks and passively accept the shock, with experimenters interpreting this as a model of depression in humans.
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) tends to focus on experiments that are not curing children's cancers as a matter of effective activism tactics, focusing on less defensible cases rather than the hardest cases, but this tactic creates pressure to maintain a strict party line against all animal experimentation even including potentially justifiable medical research.
The scale of animal suffering from food production is vastly greater than any historical human suffering because we kill approximately 200 billion vertebrate animals annually for food, compared to 8 billion humans on the planet, and inflict miserable lives on them in factory farming systems.
The learned helplessness model has been abandoned for depression because experimenters themselves came to accept that it was not a good model for depression and that the label 'learned helplessness' was even wrong—the behavior was more biologically innate than learned—but researchers subsequently proposed using it as a model for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
My Notes
Loading notes...