YouTube1h 1m· Aug 2022· cataloged

Ulysses by James Joyce: Bibliotheca Webinar


What this covers

You can find Ulysses here https://www.amazon.com/Cambridge-Centenary-Ulysses-Essays-Notes/dp/131651594X?crid=1Y9V0NJ8T3IGH&keywords=Joyce+Ulysses&qid=1659659246&sprefix=joyce+ulysses%2Caps%2C118&sr=8-1&linkCode=ll1&tag=michaelsugrue-20&linkId=9c8af6db85556b41a7e50b1e16c8c7df&language=en_US&ref_=as_li_ss_tl This is the official YouTube channel of Dr. Michael Sugrue.

Please consider subscribing to be notified of future videos, as we upload Dr. Sugrue's vast archive of lectures.

Dr. Michael Sugrue earned his BA at the University of Chicago and PhD at Columbia University.

Source description (no synthesized summary yet).

Sharpest takeaway

Joyce's Ulysses recasts Homer's epic into a modernist microcosm of human experience by compressing the Odyssey's mythic journey into a single day in 1904 Dublin, using experimental narrative techniques and layered symbolic architecture to explore consciousness, identity, and the redemptive possibility of ordinary life.

  • The novel maps Homeric encounters onto Leopold Bloom's Dublin day, with each episode corresponding to a body part, color, and art/science discipline, creating a constructed 'man' through accumulation
  • Joyce abandons omniscient narration for fragmented, stream-of-consciousness perspectives that reflect Freudian psychology—the modernist fragmentation of the unified Cartesian subject
  • The everyday prosaic (a Jewish salesman's walk through Dublin) achieves epic significance through linguistic innovation and symbolic density, celebrating the extraordinary within ordinary life

The claims · ranked52 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Each episode in Ulysses is additionally keyed to a specific color from the visible light spectrum, as well as a specific art or science discipline (poetry, history, physics, mathematics), such that the novel encodes multiple symbolic systems running in parallel with the narrative.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

not only are each of the events recounted in his journey and remember the journey motif has been holding western literature together ever since the beginning everybody's going somewhere and each of the sections refers to a body part we're building a man but it also refers to a specific color so the entire color of the visible set of the visible spectrum that gets covered too each of these sections is makes reference to or is connected to a specific color not only are they connected to colors and to body parts but each of them also calls upon specific parts of the arts and sciences like poetry or history or science or physics or math and each of those are keyed in to the events of bloom's uh journey

0.80

Joyce's stream-of-consciousness technique abandons grammar, punctuation, and the distinction between description and utterance, creating a 'chemical slurry of consciousness' that has not been 'broken up into the ordinary building blocks of our thinking which is called grammar.'

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

the most obvious and for me most difficult part of the style is that uh stream of consciousness there grammar is gone punctuation is gone uh the difference between description and utterance is gone uh what we get is a kind of how can i put it a chemical slurry of consciousness that hasn't been broken up into the ordinary uh building blocks of our thinking which is called grammar all right yeah uh so we still have nouns and verbs and adjectives but now they relate in a not in an indeterminate way because we have a whole paragraph of these things without the the markers which are called punctuation that tell us how these things are supposed to be in a logical relation

0.80

Joyce chose June 16, 1904 as the date of Ulysses specifically because it was an arbitrary, unremarkable day in Dublin with no significant historical events, allowing him to foreground the 'extraordinary within the prosaic' and present 'every man and every day' through the lens of Leopold Bloom.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

he's looking for something that is not conspicuous that doesn't have anything important happen in it because what he's looking for is the extraordinary within the prosaic okay so um he says really uh there was no great headline the next day because not all that much happened in dublin business was conducted lies were told uh people died and people were born but it was no day to remember like uh some before some extraordinary happening so what he's looking for then is every man and every day packed into this particular day

0.80

Chapter 14 (the Oxen of the Sun episode) presents a compressed linguistic history of the entire English language, progressing from Latin expressions through Germanicized pronunciation, early English, Arthurian romance conventions, and parodying roughly a dozen major figures in Western literature (including possibly Swift), allowing readers to witness the 'evolution of language compressed down...paragraph by paragraph.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

what he does is present a microcosm of the development of the entire english language he begins with some latin expressions and then moves on to uh kind of a germanicized uh pronunciation and then into early english and he starts with i think it's uh the arthur uh romance and with uh the writers associated with arthurian romance and takes it all the way up through uh uh who would be some of uh uh to through many figures including i think uh uh let me think swift might be one of them there's at least half a dozen maybe as many as a dozen different important figures in western literature that get parodied here so what you can see is the evolution of language compressed down so you can watch it happen paragraph by paragraph

0.80

Joyce fragments words into their constituent parts, which goes beyond meaning into the realm of sound and music; he loves the sound of words and structures them musically.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

so the fact that he gets poldy rather than leopold indicates their relationship now i would never have thought to subtract leo from pole but it's the kind of thing that pops into joyce's head because he's often fragmenting words into their constituent parts uh which is beyond the level of meaning it's really strange uh he loves the sound of words and there's a certain sort of music built into this

0.80

Bloom and other characters in Ulysses do not have the easy direct introspective access that Descartes claimed to have; they are unstable characters with unstable grasp of reality both inside and outside, so readers must learn to correct for the mistakes they habitually make and see 'the curvature of their psyches.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

you think back to descartes descartes thought he had a real easy direct access to his inside feelings he just looking in introspect and he would know that um bloom and the other characters here don't have that easy direct introspection they're often unstable characters with an unstable grasp of reality both inside and outside so we have to learn to correct for the mistakes they habitually make and what that means is that we're seeing some of the curvature of their psyches

0.75

Irish literary culture is uniquely dense and present in everyday life—cab drivers, waiters, and professors all have strong opinions about Joyce—because Ireland grants tax-free status to writers, allowing them to live and work in the country.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

the literary culture in dublin is not like the literary culture i've ever experienced anyplace i've done a fair amount of traveling and um when i got picked up in dublin airport to go to my hotel um my cab driver talked to me about joyce and why you thought he was a very poor writer and i'm thinking well that's unusual i thought that you know i got that one in a million cab driver who had an interest in modernist literature but no um everybody has an opinion about joyce and it doesn't matter whether it's your waiter or a professor of literature everybody has read this stuff um the irish like literature so much that there's no tax on literary writers or their income so they allow writers to live tax-free so long as they write there because they really like literature

0.74

Ulysses is a recapitulation of Homer's three-part epic structure: the Telemachy (Stephen Dedalus searching for father-figure), the Odyssey proper (Bloom's journey through Dublin encounters), and the Nostos (ironic homecoming to Molly), with each episode corresponding to a monster or trial from Homer that Bloom must navigate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

ulysses is a recapitulation of homer's telemachy that's the first couple of books where telemachus searches for his father that's stephen dallas the next and body of the work the most important and kind of heavily laden part is the odyssey and here we're going to encounter the monsters and the allures and the attractions and the seductions that odysseus did on his way back home

0.74

Joyce was educated by Jesuits, a 'Brahmin education in the Christian world,' which was demanding and sometimes cruel; he subsequently lost his faith in God, which led him to abandon belief in the traditional verities (family, country, nation).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

he's an irish catholic jesuit product which is uh it's like getting a a brahman education uh in the in the christian world they're a special group of very smart very demanding teachers and sometimes their demands were really cruel as we see in the punishment of james joyce while he's at school in the portrait he eventually loses his faith in god loses belief in god which means he loses the belief in catholicism and christianity but it also means that uh the old verities family and country and nation they all go by the wayside too

0.74

Ulysses is classified by some as an ironic hero, by others as an anti-hero, but the character Leopold Bloom has become globally recognized and has had an annual celebration (Bloomsday) named after him, showing the character's cultural resonance despite debates about his heroic status.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christy Gobel

like some of the articles i read i saw you know like they classified him as all sorts of things as an ironic hero as an anti-hero all sorts of different fact you know classifications as to how to how to how to name this protagonist but for the character that a day bloomsday has been recognized globally not necessarily as a federal hot but you know people make it a thing on on bloom's day um and the character name people know from the novel like if you're going to pull out any name from the novel most people will recognize leopold bloom

0.74

Joyce's novel was declared obscene in the United States (1934 obscenity trial) because it discussed sex, masturbation, and bodily functions with unusual frankness compared to 'polite letters' of the era, but courts eventually ruled it was experimental literature rather than pornography despite its explicit content.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

regrettably in 1934 uh 10 or 12 years after it was first published uh there was an obscenity trial in the united states and it was regarded and treated as uh subversive of public morals because it talked about sex masturbation other things that we generally left out of uh a discussion or put what we might call polite letters all right and uh this outraged the sensibilities of the sensor who was still very powerful and i made it all the way until a court had to decide that this was outs outside the realm of obscenity that this was a new complicated experimental literature but it was not pornographic despite the fact that it spoke with uh an unusual uh direction of frankness about things that didn't use that didn't generally get discussed

0.74

Joyce's location descriptions in Ulysses are so architecturally detailed and accurate that the novel could be used to 'rebuild Dublin' from memory, suggesting Joyce's purpose was to preserve Dublin's physical and social geography while simultaneously serving as an ironic commentary on its suffocating insularity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

one of the things i have i have two more main questions one of them we've kind of touched on but just the detail in this book about dublin is incredible like you know uh joyce you know joyce quoted was quoted at one point saying something along the lines of like if you needed to you could rebuild dublin based on ulysses because there is that much detail

0.74

Joyce's method requires reading with a teacher or in a group of committed readers rather than alone, because 'if your first language is not english because uh native english speakers find joyce very difficult i can hardly imagine what it'd be like to try and figure out what joyce is doing with the english language if it were your second or third language.'

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

i would if you're going to be starting at joyce and this is particularly if you're not if your first language is not english because uh native english speakers find joyce very difficult i can't hardly imagine what it'd be like to try and figure out what joyce is doing with the english language if it were your second or third language uh only a few great geniuses like say conrad have that depth of a grasp of other languages so uh it's a very difficult text do it with a teacher that's the best way to do it and if not with a teacher than with a bunch of other people who are like-minded who are also willing to make the commitment

0.74

Homer's epics (Iliad, Odyssey) and Virgil's Aeneid all have 'inelegant endings' that fail to conclude satisfyingly—the Odyssey ends with diplomatic tasks rather than Ulysses' homecoming, the Iliad ends with Achilles' compassion rather than Troy's fall—showing that epic form itself resists clean narrative closure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

epics don't end the way they should the iliad ends with uh achilles being uh compassionate to preem not with the fall of troy and the odyssey ends not with the killing of the suitors but with odysseus saying now i got to go do a whole bunch of diplomatic things and go see my dad and a whole bunch of other stuff because you've got all these loose ends to tie up um it's a very inelegant ending um even if you look at uh virgil's onion um he also has a problem of an ending

0.74

Leopold Bloom begins his day on one side of Dublin and ends on the other side at his home, but his homecoming is ironic because his wife is unfaithful, not because she was waiting faithfully like Penelope.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

he starts out at home and ends up at home but his homecoming is ironic bloom finally gets home but his wife molly bloom who's the analog of penelope in this case instead of being faithful to him is not she's involved with blazes boiling and he knows it so it's an ironic homecoming and it's an ironic heroism

0.74

Bloom encounters anti-Semitic undertones and hostility during his journey through Dublin, which is part of the novel's unflinching representation of social prejudice and ordinary human cruelty.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

uh he uh bloom gets insulted uh you know there's an anti-semitic undertone uh from there to the maternity hospital

0.73

Molly Bloom is the 'anti-Penelope' because while Homer's Penelope famously delays the suitors through her weaving (loyalty through delay), Molly is 'remarkable for her ingenious not putting off of the suitors'—she accepts Blazes Boylan's advances on the very day Bloom returns home.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

remember penelope is great for her ingenious putting off of the suitors molly is remarkable for her ingenious not putting off of the suitors uh joyce himself is going on a journey but this journey is as much interior as it is exterior

0.73

Each chapter of Ulysses corresponds to a different organ of the human body (e.g., the Sirens chapter corresponds to the ear because we hear sirens with our ears; the Aeolus chapter corresponds to the lungs because Aeolus governs the winds), creating a microcosm-macrocosm structure where each section constructs a new man.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

each of the places or each of the monsters that um that bloom leopold bloom meets um like uh oh aeolius or you know with the winds or uh cyclops and uh you know the other various dangerous ones calypso each of them corresponds to a different organ of the human body so for example the sirens correspond to the ear because that's what we hear the sirens with and uh aeolius corresponds to the lungs because he governs the winds uh cylindress correspond to the brain because they have to negotiate those aristotelian extremes and get through the middle and so what what's being done there is uh joyce is constructing a man this is the microcosm macrocosm aspect of it

0.68

The river in Bloom's journey through Dublin is connected with the idea of time and the flow of time, positioning the river as a symbol of temporal process.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

from the library we go to the river the river is connected with the idea of time and the flow of time

0.68

The novel is 'astonishingly well crafted' with 'every word every image every line...where it's supposed to be' and Joyce was 'beyond fastidious' in his expression, indicating a level of technical control and intentionality across the entire work.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

it is astonishingly well crafted every word every image every line is where it's supposed to be uh joyce was beyond fastidious when it came to uh expressing himself in print

0.68

Portrait of the Artist is a more accessible entry point to Joyce than Ulysses, and Dubliners (especially the short story 'The Dead') should be read before attempting Ulysses, as it provides stylistic preparation.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

unless you're a real uh a real glutton for punishment start with portrait because portrait while it's not an easy read by any means is considerably more direct and more accessible than ulysses then if you find you know you have a taste of joyce try something like dubliners then his short stories which are excellent remarkably deft uh someone once called uh he had a short story or actually kind of short novel perhaps uh in the russian sense uh called the dead which someone once called the best short story ever written because it's deeply moving and poignant

0.68

It is not an accident that so much of English-language literature comes from Irish writers like Oscar Wilde and William Butler Yeats; there is a distinctive Irish literary tradition.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

it's not an accident that so much of uh literature in the english language comes from irishmen like uh wild or yates in particular

0.68

Ulysses was originally published as a serial release and later as a complete novel (1922), and serial publication shaped the structure, with many subplots deriving from the episodic serial form (similar to Dickens).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

published originally as a serial release starting in 1918 and then into a novel form in 1922 ulysses is a modern parallel to homer's odyssey

0.66

Joyce focuses intensely on subjectivity and interiority, attempting to represent consciousness through language as far as possible, loading meaning and reference into his texts while building upon complex foundations, with ambitions to present all of human experience in a single day.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

joyce writes like few others uh he focuses intensely on subjectivity and interiority and he tries to represent with words as far as you can go with uh the deployment of language so uh he is always loading on meaning and reference and complexity to what started out as very complex books uh his ambitions are enormous and this is in some ways the restatement from modern times with ordinary uh democratic people um what are trials and tribulations and what our spiritual journey amounts to

0.63

Sugrue has read Ulysses with a group of friends in graduate school who were smarter than he was; they spent a whole summer reading it, took it apart and put it back together, and concluded they hardly scratched the surface of the novel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

when i read it we it was i mean we saw that it was a commitment it was a bunch of friends of mine in graduate school and i read it for a whole summer with a bunch of people that were a lot smarter than i am at the end of the summer we had finished it and we had taken it apart and put it back together and we concluded we hardly scratched the surface of the damn thing

0.62

Stephen Dedalus is young Joyce, while elder Joyce may be a combination of Leopold Bloom and Buck Mulligan, and possibly also the spirit of Finn McCool as it appears in Finnegan's Wake.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

stephen deadless is young joyce and elder joyce may be a combination of his greatest characters uh stephen deadless of course but also buck mulligan also uh uh leopold bloom and maybe also uh finn again the spirit of finn mccool as he is in joyce's novel uh finnegan's wake

0.60

The name 'Poldy' (how Molly refers to Leopold) derives from 'Leopold' with the prefix 'Leo' removed, functioning as a linguistic micro-sign of their relationship, since Molly is 'habitually unfaithful' to him—an ironic inversion of Penelope's faithfulness—such that the diminishment of his name mirrors the diminishment of his status as husband.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

molly bloom always refers to her husband leopold that's poli and what what poli is is leopold with the leo left out okay right all right she is habitually unfaithful to him right so she's an ironic penelope yep all right so the fact that he gets poldy rather than leopold indicates their relationship now i would never have thought to subtract leo from pole but it's the kind of thing that pops into joyce's head because he's often fragmenting words into their constituent parts uh which is beyond the level of meaning it's really strange uh he loves the sound of words

0.60

Stephen Dedalus, protagonist of Joyce's earlier novel 'A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man,' reappears in Ulysses as a character who has 'walked in from another novel,' making Ulysses 'the first hyper text' where narrative continuity spans multiple independent works.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

in his next novel he breaks out and this is you might want to think of this as the first hyper text okay right so somebody has walked in from another novel and said by the way here i am uh who could have done that before maybe balzac but um this is a very strange thing to do to step beyond the limits of well the story we got which is the portrait of the artist as a young man and now the artist is here again

0.60

The pubs are visited twice in Ulysses, which is typical and significant because the pub is the nexus of Irish social life—it is where people of all classes socialize at lunchtime or after work, making it a fundamental institution in Irish culture.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

the only kind of location we visit twice are pubs okay and there's a reason for that that's true there's one yeah one early one late and we're not finished with the day yet okay well no i mean uh the pub is the uh nexus of irish social life yes i mean it doesn't matter whether you're rich or poor or where you go um everybody you know at lunchtime or after after work stops off for a pint it's just the way in which people socialize

0.60

Odysseus' transformation in Homer's epic occurs through loss and stripping of his status (losing men, booty, ships, even clothing until he 'washes up on shore buck naked') leading to spiritual transformation and the wisdom to show mercy to servants after the suitors' death.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

odysseus is going to have uh a transformation he's going to be uh spiritually transformed as he is in the epic remember that eventually he loses all his men all his booty from troy all the ships even all his clothing he washes up on shore buck naked all right there's that comic scene when he's found the key thing here is that joyce is recapitulating those in each chapter

0.59

Dubliners contains a short novel called 'The Dead,' which someone once called the best short story ever written because it is deeply moving and poignant.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

someone once called uh he had a short story or actually kind of short novel perhaps uh in the russian sense uh called the dead which someone once called the best short story ever written because it's deeply moving and poignant that's to be found in dubliners

0.56

The opening of Ulysses 'flows like water' when read aloud, suggesting that Joyce's prose achieves a lyrical, nearly musical quality that rewards oral recitation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue (first citation); Christy Gobel (second citation)

it flows like water and when we find stephen deadless i suppose pursuing the uncreated conscience of his race uh he is part of a larger tapestry

0.56

Ulysses intentionally lacks a clear narrative resolution (mirroring Homer's Odyssey and War and Peace), such that the novel ends without definitive closure because life itself continues and the universe keeps flowing; this reflects Joyce's artistic principle that you must eventually 'walk away from a piece' rather than impose artificial finality.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

it's a little bit like the ending of war and peace i'm not talking about the epilogues yeah but if you may if you paid your dues and gotten you know all thousand pages through war and peace you'll find out that it ends but doesn't really have a conclusion because it's meant to represent the universe and the universe keeps on flowing on so at some point uh tolstoy says look my story is already too complicated i'm gonna cut this off joyce's ulysses is in some ways like that in other words uh life continues on there's no reason why we shouldn't have another chapter except that well um there's a point at which you have to walk away from a piece

0.56

Molly's final affirmation ('yes yes') functions as a life-affirming conclusion despite her simultaneous infidelity with Blazes Boylan on the same day, making the novel's ending deeply ironic and ambiguous rather than clearly redemptive.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

it now ends with molly's affirmation affirmation of being married to leopold bloom and or poldy as she calls him and uh also um affirmation of the world and of life i would call it in the niche and sense a life-affirming work

0.56

The sequence of locations Bloom visits in Ulysses (pub, pharmacy, library, river, pub, maternity hospital, brothel) mirrors the progression of human experience: birth, death, sickness, health, and sexuality are compressed into a single day's journey, such that the city itself becomes a diagram of human life.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

from the library we go to the river the river is connected with the idea of time and the flow of time uh then back to the pub a different pub this time all right uh he uh bloom gets insulted uh you know there's an anti-semitic undertone uh from there to the maternity hospital why well i mean we need new life because i'm sure people were dying actually we passed a a funeral earlier on so we have to cram every possible human experience in here birth death uh the difficulties and anxieties of life and then finally from from the hospital we go to the brothel why well this is where tomorrow which is where nine months from now those babies are coming from right so we have sex we have death we have birth uh i don't know that we've left we have sickness we have health i don't know that we've left all that much out

0.56

Joyce's stylistic variation across chapters (changing narrative voice, genre, and linguistic register) reflects Freud's fragmentation of the unified Cartesian subject—abandoning the omniscient narrator in favor of showing consciousness as inherently fractured, unstable, and unreliable.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

the fragmentation of subjectivity and of the self and that fragmentation was performed by sigmund freud he said you have a conscious part but you also have an unconscious part and what that is is actually the philosophy of mind analog of breaking the atom into its constituent parts you see um for for descartes the cogito the ego the individual is completely integral it's an atom but when freud smashes that atom you get all kinds of interesting epistemological problems and the same thing happened in physics now with joyce the same thing is happening in literature he's fragmented the subject you only have bits and pieces who are only in intermittent contact with each other so you get these flawed strange perspectives

0.56

'A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man' is autobiographical and takes the form of a 'portrait in time' using words rather than paint, such that Joyce shifts the artistic medium of portraiture from visual art into literary form.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

his early novel uh stephen deadless is autobiographical and it's a portrait but not in space it's a portrait in time and not using paint but using words so what he's doing is taking the idea of the portrait shifting uh art forms and then as he shoehorns it into the uh the structure of the novel

0.56

Stephen Dedalus's final aspiration in Portrait—'I go on to encounter reality for the millionth time and to forge within the smithy of my soul the uncreated conscience of my race'—represents him as undertaking self-consciously what Homer did for the Greeks: creating a literary conscience for his nation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

i go on to encounter reality for the millionth time and to forge within the smithy of my soul the uncreated conscience of my race it flows like water and when we find stephen deadless i suppose pursuing the uncreated conscience of his race uh he is part of a larger tapestry and joyce is giving us the very big view the synoptic view of a bloom but also of a number of other characters

0.56

Bloom is denied a 'sinister' transformation (unlike tragic epics) but instead remains memorable 'for being an ordinary guy,' making the novel's heroism fundamentally different from traditional epic—not bloodstained glory but everyday endurance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

bloom has had the lion taken out of him and uh the character is certainly one of the most memorable but in a way like without the sinister implications like kafka he's memorable for being an ordinary guy

0.56

Writing a novel after Joyce is 'like writing a symphony after Beethoven's Ninth'—subsequent writers face the problem of overcoming Joyce's achievement, which has exhausted possibilities in the form.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

trying to write a novel in english after joyce is like trying to write a symphony after beethoven's ninth i mean even the best throw up their hands and say i should find another hobby because i'm not going to get beyond that

0.56

What holds together different contemporary retellings of the Odyssey (Ulysses, Omeros, and others) is the sea, which is both a literal space and a symbol of time, journey, and transformation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

what holds them all together is the sea and it's sloshing around i mean think of aeneas right uh running the mediterranean so he can get to italy and uh of course odysseus himself um when we get to joyce um we don't have the right size heroes for uh a genuinely tragic result here i don't think instead what we get is a mock epic

0.56

Joyce's portrait of the artist doesn't provide a central backbone to the narrative structure without the tradition of Homer; the novel is held together architecturally by its parallelism to the Odyssey, providing continuity that the introspective, Nietzschean indeterminacy would otherwise lack.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

portrait of the artist is certainly a niche novel and in many respects the outline here is uh ni-chan in its indeterminacy but also um it uh doesn't provide us with uh a central backbone there's a whole bunch of episodes but the only backbone we have is the tradition that comes out of homer all right it wouldn't hold together otherwise

0.56

The novel depicts life as an 'ongoing big event'—one does not need to destroy a city (as in classical epics) for life itself to have epic significance; the prosaic is elevated to epic status through language, structure, and depth of representation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Christy Gobel

let's try to celebrate the prosaic and say that life itself is an ongoing big event you don't have to destroy a city for that to be the case

0.53

Leopold Bloom is a Jewish advertising salesman in 1904 Dublin, a statistically improbable choice that Joyce made deliberately to allow for wordplay and symbolic resonance (the name 'Bloom' enabling puns on flowers, fertility, and cyclical renewal) while using an outsider figure to critique Dublin society.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

in turn of the century dublin um my understanding is that there weren't all that many uh jewish uh advertising salesmen in dublin at the time it would have been 99 catholic and they would have had all kinds of things to do but the you know the random wheel the kind of bingo or the lotto the choice that uh joyce made allows him to uh um play with words in ways that are both revealing and i mean brilliant

0.52

Joyce was influenced by Nietzsche's critique of Socratic philosophy and Plato's rationalism, and sought to revive Homeric heroic values through Ulysses as a modernist response to what Nietzsche saw as the West's philosophical wrong turn away from pre-Socratic wisdom.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

joyce is very influenced by nietzsche and nietzsche's appreciation of homer uh remember nietzsche thinks that oh we went wrong with that socrates guy and then plato was even worse yeah so he would like it to go back to those homeric heroic values now uh portrait of the artist is certainly a niche novel and in many respects the outline here is uh ni-chan in its indeterminacy

0.52

The tension between Joyce's breaking down of logical relations in literature and analytic philosophy's elevation and absolutization of sentence precision represents a fundamental cultural conflict between art and science in the early 20th century.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

one of the funny things about joyce is that just about the time that he's breaking down the logical relationship between sentences uh analytic philosophy is elevating individual sentences and absolutizing the precision with which they break them down so you've got people in the culture pulling on both ends of the rope and that's in some ways the tension between art and science in the era just before the first world war

0.47

Homer's Ulysses is superior to Shakespeare's Hamlet as a literary character because Ulysses is 'a complete character'—simultaneously a father, son, commander, warrior, friend, and husband—whereas Hamlet's greatness derives only from his specific circumstance of being a murdered king's son.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (attributed quote, not direct statement)

joyce once was quoted to say that homer's character ulysses and i'm paraphrasing here that homer's character ulysses is the best all-around character a complete character he compared ulysses to hamlet something that he kind of references in um his novel as well saying that hamlet was a great character but just a son like everything that inspired hamlet was because he was the son of the king who got murdered ulysses was a father a son a commander a warrior a friend a husband and so much more

0.47

The Irish English dialect is particularly musical and lends itself to discovering 'the music and the meter inside language,' which is why Joyce and other Irish poets (and Caribbean poets like Derek Walcott) excel at linguistic innovation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

i think that there are certain dialects of english that lend themselves um more than others to that certain kind of musical uh element in language i think the irish version of english is one of them and that's part of why they produce so many poets but also i think the caribbean version of english uh if you imagine some a great poet like derek walcott um that too seems to me very musical and lil thing uh they have something some similarities to the irish version of english but it lends itself to finding the music and the meter inside of language and that's what joyce is great at

0.47

Dublin's small, close-knit social community (where most people are connected through mutual acquaintances) is 'absolutely suffocating' because 'everybody knows you and your family and your parents' and individuals 'can't live as an individual without having people impose themselves on you,' which explains why Joyce had to leave Ireland.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

it's also indicates why joyce as a as an individual had to leave it's absolutely suffocating everybody knows you and your family and your parents and what people would think and you really can't live as an individual without having people impose themselves on you so he's doing he he's going back but he's looking at at dublin like a ghost would all right

0.25

Dante claimed to be one of the seven greatest poets who ever lived and admitted Homer into that group, whereas Joyce is 'more flexible and perhaps not quite so megalomaniacal' in his relationship to Homer.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

dante where he announced that he was one of the seven greatest poets that ever lived that he was willing to admit homer into that august group but uh uh i'd be inclined to think that uh uh joyce is more uh more flexible and perhaps uh uh not quite so megalo megalomaniacal

0.25

Yeats (like Joyce) had 'a strange magical power with words' that enabled him to find music and meaning in language in ways that are uncanny and difficult to explain rationally.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

he reminds me of yates who had that same sort of strange magical power with words that i couldn't think of in a million years

0.20

The novel is 'well worth the effort' and 'a big advantage if you have some time to put into it because it really is a commitment,' but with guided reading it will inspire readers to want to engage with the book.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Dr. Michael Sugrue

this is well worth the effort and it's a big advantage if you have some time to put into it because it really is a commitment but um with any luck this short discussion of a long book will get you to uh want to take a look and want to read it it's well worth your time