factual

What-If Questions Are Tractable Math Games

Even counterfactual or counter-logical 'what if' questions are tractable because they are rule-governed language games: asking what the world would be like under an inverse-cube gravity law is just a different math problem, and even asking what you could do if you could trisect an angle with straightedge and compass (a provable impossibility) is answerable by treating it as adding a trisecting instrument.

factualpending

Speaker

Tim Maudlin

Evidence Quote

if you want to play the game of what if in many cases it's not hard to figure out the rules of the game so you can see what counts is saying oh yeah that that would be what would happen

Source

318 - Physics PhilosophyMaking Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:58:49 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...