causal

Counterfactuals Are Made True By Laws, Not Possibilities

Counterfactual claims (e.g., 'if I had let go of the rock it would have fallen') are made true not by ghostly unactualized events but by the actual laws of nature: possibilities do not exert pressure on actuality because only actual things push things around; the laws determine which counterfactuals are true, so possibility is grounded in laws rather than laws in possibility.

causalpending

Speaker

Tim Maudlin

Evidence Quote

i don't think possibilities put any pressure on actuality right because possibilities as it were don't they don't exist in a certain full-blooded sense they don't push things around only actual things can push things around

Source

318 - Physics PhilosophyMaking Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:58:49 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...