Barry Weiss
About
Journalist, author of 'How to Fight Anti-semitism', NYT opinion staff writer
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Barry Weiss's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Barry Weiss (20 of 36)
Celebrity endorsements have lost their power because the mystique of celebrity has been deconstructed; Hollywood celebrities are now widely viewed as 'leftwing ditto heads' who are not allowed to articulate independent thought, making their endorsements less valuable than those of podcasters, entrepreneurs, and other outsiders.
Peter Teal was the first venture capitalist in Silicon Valley to publicly embrace Trump in 2016 and suffered significant professional consequences, including losing his partner position at Y Combinator and criticism from prominent tech leaders like Chris Sacca and Jason Calacanis, but this isolation has reversed with the 2024 election as many tech titans including Bill Amman, Marc Andreessen, David Sachs, and Elon Musk have joined the Trump coalition.
People who are reliable Democrats and liberals who either sat out the 2024 election or voted Trump for the first time did not do so because they like Trump but because they wanted to give 'a middle finger to the capital' like in The Hunger Games analogy—they rejected the feeling of being controlled by an out-of-touch elite enforcing conformity.
The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswami, represents the triumph of the counter-elite—a coalition of outsiders who ran against an insular, celebrity-backed establishment and won, positioning themselves to reshape both government and American culture.
Twitter Files Were a Truth and Reconciliation Effort
The Twitter Files were Elon Musk's attempt at an informal truth and reconciliation commission, opening the company's inner workings to independent journalists because he understood the platform had lost public trust by claiming to be one thing while secretly being another and cooperating with government in ways that would make Americans uncomfortable.
Source Transparency Doesn't Invalidate Journalism
Every source who leaks documents has an agenda; the unusual thing about the Twitter Files is that the source was entirely public and transparent about his agenda, so critics attacking journalistic practice are avoiding confronting the actual story.
Twitter Files Searches Were Laborious and Anecdotal
The journalists did not have organized files but could only run highly directed e-discovery searches on at most two laptops shared among up to eight journalists, producing thousands of emails per query, which forced difficult choices to target known public stories and inherently produced an anecdotal rather than comprehensive picture.
Jim Baker Was Secretly Vetting the Searches
Early Twitter Files searches returned garbage because the lawyer actually running them, Jim Baker, worked for Twitter and was himself one of the people the journalists were trying to investigate; once Musk learned this, Baker was fired and subsequent files showed no evidence of tampering.
Twitter Slack Resembled a Gender Studies Classroom
Public Slack conversations at Twitter resembled a gender studies classroom at Oberlin, with employees openly discussing how J.K. Rowling's tweets fell under the dehumanization policy and banding together to get her kicked off, reflecting that institutions are made of people whose ideological homogeneity shapes what gets labeled hate speech or misinformation.
Suppressing Vindicated Views Radicalizes People
When someone is labeled a conspiracy theorist or grandma-killer for a view that later turns out to be vindicated, it becomes easy for them to fall down a rabbit hole and move further into genuine insanity, so it is essential to keep the parameters of healthy debate as wide as possible to prevent people from migrating to extremist platforms.
Treat People as Adults Not Children
The lesson of recent years is that people must be treated as adults given sophisticated information, not pedantically like children, because when you simplify and propagandize, people see through it and respond by doing their own 'research,' leading to diminished trust in legacy media, universities, and other sense-making institutions.
Twitter Actively Made Viewpoints Untouchable
People inside Twitter actively worked to make certain people and viewpoints untouchable—as in the shadow banning of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya—and many of those viewpoints have since been vindicated, profoundly shaping public conversation about how to respond to COVID.
My Notes
Loading notes...