Daniel Goleman
About
Harvard psychologist, leadership researcher
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Daniel Goleman's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Daniel Goleman (18)
The special state of consciousness in the highest-level meditators matches descriptions in classical meditation literature of states called 'liberation,' 'enlightenment,' or 'awake,' but science has no existing vocabulary to capture what this state is, and advanced meditators describe it as 'very spacious' where you are 'wide open' and 'prepared for whatever may come.'
Modern multitasking and digital device use significantly challenge focused attention: people check email approximately 50 times per day and Facebook approximately 20 times per day, fragmenting attention across numerous tasks, making focused attention an 'endangered species' in contemporary life.
Mindfulness shifts one's relationship to emotional and cognitive experience by allowing observation of thoughts and feelings as separate from the self, which disempowers them and distinguishes this from the experience of being depressed or anxious where one is identified with and caught in the mental content.
Beginners in mindfulness meditation show improved stress response immediately, including reduced activity in the amygdala (the brain region that triggers fight-or-flight-or-freeze responses), making them calmer in the face of stress, which is a benefit that appears from the beginning of practice rather than requiring extensive training.
Across all major religious and philosophical traditions (Christian, Buddhist, Jewish, Hindu literature), the consistent teaching of meditative practices is that one should become less focused on oneself and more compassionate and open to others, emphasizing that meditation naturally leads toward decreased selfishness and increased care for others.
Olympic-level meditators (10,000 to 62,000 lifetime meditation hours) are genuinely selfless people who remain nourishing and enjoyable to be with because they maintain focused attention on the person they're with and orient toward being of service, distinguishing them from people who merely suppress selfish impulses.
Meditation research exploded from 3 to 6000+ studies
When Goleman and Davidson did their dissertations there were only three peer-reviewed articles to cite on meditation, but decades later the field had grown to more than 6,000 papers, of which they used rigorous standards to select about 60, with the explosion driven largely by neuroimaging work.
Scale-versus-depth tradeoff in meditation practice
There is a tradeoff in meditation between many people doing a little bit (e.g. mass mindfulness in schools and businesses, which is a thin experience but goes to scale) and a few people practicing very intensely and deeply (monks, nuns, yogis who go the deepest), with traditions imported to the West leaving much behind to become accessible to a larger swath of people.
A wandering mind is an unhappy mind
A famous Harvard study published in Science monitored how distracted people are during the day and found that the more one's mind wanders in distraction, the more depressed one becomes, supporting the idea that cultivating concentration has special value as an antidote to a social trend toward ever more seductive digital distraction.
Flow is experiential fusion, not meta awareness
Meditation is often equated with flow, but flow states—like a rock climber totally engrossed in climbing or watching an engrossing movie—are cases of experiential fusion with no meta awareness; if flow were equivalent to meditation, all rock climbers would be enlightened, which they are not, illustrating that concentration-induced bliss is a different path from meta awareness, which yields equanimity rather than transient bliss.
Altered states have a half-life; you remain the same person
The problem with altered states is that after you come down you are 'the same schmuck you were before you went up'—as illustrated by Davidson's blissful first Goenka retreat experience that crashed quickly upon returning to a cold family reception—because these blissful states have a half-life, which is precisely what drove Goleman and Davidson toward investigating lasting altered traits.
The West uses meditation against its original purpose
The way the West uses meditation—for feeling better, productivity, and stress reduction—says more about Western values than about the original tradition, whose point was always deconstructing the self; meditation was not developed to cure illness but to cultivate awakening, a fundamentally different project, and the benefits the West seeks are merely byproducts of a different aim focused on less self-concern and more availability to the present and to others.
The Dalai Lama's mandate to study and spread the methods
Around the year 2000 at a Mind and Life meeting, the Dalai Lama told Davidson that his tradition has many methods for managing disturbing emotions and urged scientists to take them out of the religious context, study them rigorously in the lab, and if beneficial, spread them widely—a directive that helped catalyze modern meditation research.
My Notes
Loading notes...