Glen Weyl
About
Economist
Cast within
No topic-region cast yet — this appears once Glen Weyl's compiled claims are aligned into a topic region's argument tree.
Claims by Glen Weyl (20 of 92)
Use trusted local and private institutions, not federal
Because there is a systemic lack of trust in the federal government, the strategy should reserve for Washington only the funding and supply-chain coordination that genuinely require it, while empowering higher-trust state and local governments and leading businesses to execute and lead public communication—potentially via an interstate compact where federal funding is administered by states and staffed by the private sector.
Three pillars: testing, tracing, supported isolation
An effective pandemic strategy rests on three pillars—testing, tracing, and supported isolation—where isolation must be accompanied by public supports (medical treatment, food, income, job protection) sufficient to give people a strong reason to isolate, especially those with limited economic means who would otherwise face hardship from leaving work.
Pandemic testing board via interstate compact
The coordinating body—a pandemic testing board—is best structured as an interstate compact governed by a consortium of governors as final authority, who appoint a board staffed mostly by retired generals and business leaders plus labor representation, rather than as a single national forum.
Tenure and prizes should reward public engagement
Reforming economics requires universities and prize committees to place much greater weight on a scholar's ability to bring ideas into public discourse rather than relying mainly on the esteem of colleagues, even though designing the right metrics for this is difficult.
Medical-match-style admissions force costly guessing
The Gale-Shapley medical match, where applicants rank all institutions before knowing which will admit them, forces either huge due diligence across institutions or guessing about admission chances—an ineffective process—whereas the US undergraduate model, in which applicants learn who might admit them before committing, is more sensible and could be improved with finely-graded staged matching that clears top mutual matches first.
Federalism forces a centralization-vs-travel-restriction tradeoff
Because of the US federal structure, the country faces a choice between centralizing power more than is desirable (reducing scope for valuable experimentation) and allowing some restrictions on travel across localities—possibly via identity certificates—as Canada did across provinces.
Friedman and Rawls share a vision but miss increasing returns
Milton Friedman's Capitalism and Freedom is very similar to Rawls despite the left loving Rawls and hating Friedman, but both dramatically underestimated the importance of increasing-returns phenomena; Friedman's implicit decreasing-returns model led him to treat monopolies as merely temporary, missing that increasing-returns phenomena that create monopolies are the very foundation of civilization.
Serology and symptom resolution as immunity proxies
Serological tests, once reliable, can indicate convalescence and at least temporary immunity via a specific antibody, and it is believed (though not certain, given some South Korean reinfection reports) that during a post-symptomatic period viral shedding is low, so recovered-asymptomatic people can rejoin the population's status absent symptom resurgence even without a serology test.
Quadratic voting best used for eliciting preferences
Quadratic voting would be most powerful in the pandemic for eliciting informed, rich feedback about what elements of the response people value most—enabling large-scale remote deliberation that reveals which social-distancing restrictions hurt most and which are most acceptable—rather than necessarily changing how much society values human lives overall.
Talent is seeing the field from inside and outside
The key talent to look for in young economists, beyond hard work, is the ability to internalize the field while simultaneously seeing beyond how it shapes them—living within the world of economics and also viewing it from the outside.
Matching mechanisms could fund cultural innovation
A pool of funding directed into RadicalxChange-style matching mechanisms could improve platforms like Patreon and Kickstarter to fund cultural innovation, helping sustain morale while people are separated, since the internet shift has eliminated the in-person gigs that supported much of the music sector.
Singapore over-relied on digital tracing
Singapore's resurgence likely stemmed from putting too much confidence in a Bluetooth digital tracing system that got very low take-up, pulling back on manual tracing prematurely, and—because manual tracing covers public spaces poorly while the digital tools failed to cover them—allowing redensification of public spaces too quickly.
Employers owe negligence standard, not strict liability
Employers should bear a negligence requirement to use the best available tests, but not strict liability for any erroneous test result, because strict liability would discourage testing; a pandemic testing board's guidance would, under common-law deference, likely shape how most courts treat such liability though not uniformly.
Planned closure beats repeated unexpected shutdowns
Reopening under current conditions will, per all epidemiological models, cause a disease resurgence requiring renewed lockdowns; keeping things closed another month-plus is less damaging than sudden, unexpected, recurring shutdowns, which destroy businesses' ability to plan—whereas a planned period of bridge loans and Fed bailouts can be legislated ahead of time.
Weyl's intellectual identity is Hegelian synthesis
Weyl's unified self-understanding is that he is fundamentally oriented toward Hegelian synthesis—finding persuasive but seemingly contradictory positions and fusing them syncretically in his mind—a recurring theme traceable to a high-school capstone on 'conservative liberalism' that reads like his recent work.
Frequent testing twice weekly equals immune status
Testing frequently enough—probably twice a week rather than once—should grant a person equal status to someone shown to be immune, and certificates (like passports) for either immunity or frequent negative tests would be issued, but only after enough tests exist for the basic population-wide regime and primarily for sensitive professions near vulnerable populations.
Being an island is not enough for containment
Geographic isolation is not a comprehensive containment strategy: plenty of islands that restricted travel have failed (the UK being a notable example), and for most high-prevalence US population centers, treating yourself as an island will not accomplish much, though it can work for the few localities with low enough prevalence.
Two root causes block US testing scale-up
US testing fails to scale because of two distinct problems: a coordination failure along the supply chain (no clear demand signal reaches reagent and test-kit producers, so they won't make fixed-cost investments to repurpose manufacturing) and many small innovations near the consumer that require heavy regulatory engagement to deploy rapidly.
Most isolation happens at home, not facilities
In the Asian countries most successful at containment, the vast majority of people isolated at home—sometimes even apart from their families—with dedicated facilities like specific hotels used only for the small minority of visitors from abroad lacking a residence in the country.
My Notes
Loading notes...